Cozy Mystery Books for Romance Readers: 11 Must-Read Series with Romance and Whodunits
Looking to shake up your reading routine but still crave that comforting, heartwarming vibe? If you’re a romance reader ready to explore cozy mysteries, I’ve got you covered! Cozy mysteries deliver small-town charm, quirky characters, and a touch of romance—all with a side of whodunit fun. Let’s dive into what you can expect, what you’ll love, and a list of perfect cozy mysteries to start with.
This post contains affiliate links. That means we receive a small commission at no cost to you from any purchases you make through these links.
What to Expect When Trying Cozy Mysteries
If you’re new to cozy mysteries, here’s the rundown:
- Small Town Charm: Most cozy mysteries are set in tight-knit communities where everyone knows each other. Think bookshops, cafés, and craft stores as backdrops.
- Amateur Sleuths: Forget hard-boiled detectives—these stories often feature everyday people like bakers, librarians, or scrapbook shop owners solving crimes.
- Closed Door: Violence is minimal, and the crime-solving takes center stage. No graphic scenes here—just a satisfying puzzle to solve.
- Light Romance: While the focus is on the mystery, many cozies sprinkle in romantic subplots. Expect slow-burn relationships and cozy chemistry.
Why Romance Readers Will Love Cozy Mysteries
- Quirky Characters: Just like in romance, cozies thrive on memorable, well-developed characters. Think best friends, nosy neighbors, and adorable pets who often help solve the crime.
- Series Vibes: Many cozy mysteries come in long-running series, so you can binge multiple books with familiar characters and settings.
- Themed Fun: Cozy mysteries often revolve around specific themes—food, books, crafts—which add a unique twist to the plot.
Cozy Mystery Recommendations for Romance Readers
If you’re ready to give cozy mysteries a shot, here are some beginner-friendly series with romance vibes:
The Spice Shop Mysteries by Leslie Budewitz
Set in Seattle’s bustling Pike Place Market, this series follows Pepper Reece, the owner of a spice shop, as she stumbles upon murder while running her shop. With clever wordplay, engaging clues, and a warm community feel, it’s perfect for readers wanting cozy charm with a dash of culinary flair.
Key Themes: Culinary mystery, small business, amateur sleuth, friendship.
Grab the first book on Amazon: Assault and Pepper
The Scrapbooking Mysteries by Laura Childs
Set in the heart of New Orleans, this series features Carmela Bertrand, a scrapbook store owner with a knack for solving crimes. With Southern charm, intriguing plot twists, and a splash of romance, this cozy series blends craft store vibes with page-turning mysteries.
Key Themes: Crafts, Southern charm, female friendships, romance.
Grab the first book on Amazon: Keepsake Crimes
The Coffeehouse Mysteries by Cleo Coyle
Clare Cosi manages a historic coffeehouse in New York City and becomes involved in complex murder investigations. With a mix of rich coffee culture, clever clues, and a sprinkle of romance, this series balances city life with cozy sleuthing.
Key Themes: Urban setting, coffee culture, amateur sleuth, romance.
Grab the first book on Amazon: On What Grounds
Related: Check out our interview with Cleo Coyle
The Bibliophile Mysteries by Kate Carlisle
Bookbinder Brooklyn Wainwright restores rare books while unraveling literary-themed murders. This charming series combines literary references, romantic moments, and intriguing puzzles, making it ideal for book lovers.
Key Themes:Books, craftsmanship, light romance, bookish humor.
Grab the first book on Amazon: Homicide in Hardcover
The Fixer-Upper Mysteries by Kate Carlisle
Shannon Hammer, a skilled contractor, renovates historical homes while getting tangled in local murder cases. With a blend of craftsmanship, romance, and suspense, this series hits all the right cozy notes.
Key Themes: Home renovation, small town, romance, strong female lead.
Grab the first book on Amazon: A High-End Finish
The Mainely Needlepoint Mysteries by Lea Wait
Angie Curtis returns to her small hometown in Maine to run her grandmother’s needlepoint shop, only to find herself solving local murders. With a strong focus on community, family, and personal growth, this series is both heartwarming and suspenseful.
Key Themes: Needlepoint, small-town life, family relationships, personal growth.
Grab the first book on Amazon: Dangling by a Thread
The Tara Holloway series by Diane Kelly
Tara Holloway is an IRS special agent who balances tax fraud investigations with a side of murder-solving. Full of humor, quirky characters, and unexpected twists, this series keeps the mystery light and fun.
Key Themes: Humor, law enforcement, romance, quirky characters.
Grab the first book on Amazon: Death, Taxes and a French Manicure
The Cupcake Bakery Mysteries by Jenn McKinlay
Melanie Cooper and Angie DeLaura, best friends and cupcake bakery owners, find themselves frequently solving murders while whipping up sweet treats. With mouthwatering desserts and heartfelt friendships, this cozy series is a delight.
Key Themes: Baking, friendship, humor, romance.
Grab the first book on Amazon: Sprinkle with Murder
The Hayley Powell Food and Cocktails Mystery by Lee Hollis
Food columnist Hayley Powell becomes an amateur sleuth after being accused of murder. This cozy series is packed with recipes, humor, and a side of romance.
Key Themes: Food writing, small town, humor, recipes.
Grab the first book on Amazon: Death of a Kitchen Diva
The Zodiac Mystery Series by Connie di Marco
Astrologer Julia Bonatti uses her star charts to help solve crimes in San Francisco. This unique cozy blends astrology, murder, and personal growth in a refreshing twist on the genre.
Key Themes: Astrology, personal growth, urban setting, unique sleuth.
Grab the first book on Amazon: The Madness of Mercury
The Booktown Mystery Series by Lorna Barrett
Set in the charming town of Stoneham, known for its bookstores, Tricia Miles, a bookstore owner, becomes an amateur detective when murders disrupt the town’s literary charm. Perfect for book lovers with a taste for cozy whodunits.
Key Themes: Books, small town, community, female friendships.
Grab the first book on Amazon: Murder is Binding
If you’re a romance reader curious about cozy mysteries, you’re in for a treat! They offer the same comforting vibes, heartwarming characters, and satisfying storytelling—just with a touch of mystery. Give one of these series a try, and let me know your favorites in the comments!
Want more book recs like these? Subscribe to my Substack for cozy, romantic, and mysterious picks every week!
You may also like:
Don’t miss a thing! Join our Susbtack and you’ll be the first to know when there’s new bookish content and recommendations posted across all our book platforms!
Pin it for later
I’ve had that Diane Kelly on my list for a while and also Cleo Coyle. Love the blend of slow burn romance and mystery so I’ll have to check the others out.